Free Shipping on Orders $199+

Growing Zone: | Garden in
Find your Growing Zone!

Pie, Tart, Sour or Sweet Cherry? What’s the difference?

Pie, Tart, Sour or Sweet Cherry? What’s the difference? - Nature Hills Nursery

Whitney Laritson |

It’s the age-old question, what’s the difference between all these cherry tree varieties? Ok, so maybe it’s not considered an age-old question, but it’s certainly one many ask and for good reason.

Cherry trees are beloved across the world. Partly because of their beautiful blossoms and partly their scrumptious fruit. Picking a few off of the backyard tree makes the perfect snack for warm summer days lounging on the patio.

However, you’ll want to make sure you’ve picked the best cherry tree for the job at hand. Will you be snacking right off the tree or are you hoping to bake a county fair award-winning pie? The answer will determine which variety you want.

I Want a Pie Cherry Tree for my Cherry Pie Filling

cherries in a pie

Ok, great! Pies are superb and cherries are certainly a key ingredient in desserts in general. You’re looking to get your hands on some sour cherry trees. They’re quite tart when taken right off the tree but absolutely explode with flavor when used for baking!

Add in a healthy helping of sugar and maybe a little butter and you’ll have some of the best jelly or jam to can and eat with a little peanut butter on bread in the coming months. You could give them as holiday gifts but, just between us, you’ll want to keep all of it for yourself!

Can I Get Tart Cherry Juice from Sour Cherries?

The answer, absolutely! Sour cherry varieties are preferred when making juice. Many consider Romeo Dwarf (Prunus cerasus 'Romeo') the best tree for the job because of the plethora of tart red cherries it produces along with it’s easy to maintain height.

There are plenty of ways to juice your harvest. You can pit and throw them into a juicer, crush them by hand, or blend them. Try taking advantage of the health benefits by taking a few frozen cherries and adding them to your morning smoothie!

Grow your own to gain access to a plentiful harvest. However, a little help in discerning which trees are which never hurt anybody! Some tree varieties have helpful names that identify them as sour but most don’t. No need to fret we’ve got a list of the best sour cherry tree varieties.

montmorency blooming
Montmorency - Widely accepted as the most popular sour varieties, Montmorency (Prunus cerasus 'Montmorency') blooms brilliant snow-white flowers in the spring that are followed by bright red fruit. It’s self-fertile, so you’ll only need one tree but we’re pretty sure you’ll want more!

Early Richmond - The abundance of stunning white blooms each spring is just one of many incredible traits of the Early Richmond Cherry tree (Prunus cerasus 'Early Richmond'). Sour cherry trees have a notoriously quick harvest season and this tree can help extend that by a week or two. Instead of waiting for summer to pick your soon-to-be pie filling, this tree’s fruit will be ready as spring is winding down.

Meteor cherry
Meteor - Meteor (Prunus cerasus 'Meteor') is a sour cherry tree and a pretty fantastic one at that. It’ll give you a show of lovely white blossoms in the spring that will take your breath away! Meteor is self-pollinating with its fruit ready to harvest mid-season. You’ll want to prepare yourself though, this tree can yield quite a bit of fruit, sometimes up to 50 pounds on a single tree!

What Can I Do With a Sweet Cherry?

Sweet Cherry Trees are best at producing heaps of delicious fruits for eating fresh off the tree. A mature tree will produce enough fruit to make a single person all but burst! You can always share with a friend or keep these all to yourself.

Sweet Cherry Trees

Again, trying to figure out which trees are which can be confusing. That’s why we’ve made a list of our favorite sweet cherry trees.

Bing - When thinking about the most popular sweet tree variety, it’s impossible not to think of Bing (Prunus avium 'Bing'). It’s positively one of the finest and most famous of the sweet cherry varieties. Each year, Bing produces large, delicious fruits with smooth, glossy skin. This is the cherry that set the standard for all others for over 100 years!

This is another variety that will require a pollinator in order to fruit. Van (Prunus avium 'Van'), Rainier, Stella, and Lapins (Prunus avium 'Lapins') all work wonderfully. Like other cherries, Bing’s fruit is high in antioxidants and is a refreshing and healthy snack on those hot summer days!

Stella - Stella Cherry Trees (Prunus avium 'Stella') are just about everything you’d want in a sweet cherry tree. It’ll give you beautiful red-pink blooms in the spring for an ornamental look but its real show comes mid-season when it’s time to harvest!

Stella is self-fruitful and will produce an abundance of heart-shaped, shiny black-red fruit with delectable red flesh. These plump, firm, sweet cherries resist that pesky cracking you might come across in other cherry varieties. While you don’t need a partner for this tree to give you fruit, Stella makes a great pollinator for other varieties!

Rainier - This semi-dwarf cherry tree is a crowd favorite! Perhaps you’ve come across and enjoyed a bag of these decadent yellow and red fruits from your local Farmer’s Market? They certainly are delicious once harvested mid-season, they won’t last long before becoming a tasty treat. Don’t even get us started on this trees' gorgeous white and pale pink spring flowers!

Rainier Cherry trees (Prunus avium 'Rainier') will need a pollinator in order to produce fruit. We suggest coupling it with a Van, Lapins, Bing, or Stella to enjoy the largest harvest possible! As an added bonus, keeping Rainier to a manageable height is easy with some light pruning each year!

Let’s Talk Pollination

You might find yourself asking the question, “Do you need two cherry trees to pollinate each other in order to get fruit?”

blooming cherry tree in a park

It’s a great question and the answer is both yes and no. Some cherry trees are self-pollinating and others require a partner. One thing to keep in mind is that sweet cherry tree varieties will not pollinate sour varieties.

It can be a lot of information and feel like a bit of a headache but here at Nature Hills Nursery, we’ll list whether the tree you’re looking at is self-pollinating or not. If the answer is no, and it’ll need a pollinator partner, we’ll list those for you so you won’t have to drive yourself crazy trying to figure all that out on your own.

Cherry trees are amazing additions to your garden and being an expert on the types of cherry trees out there shouldn’t have to be a prerequisite to having one of your own. We have all the information you’ll need on your cherry tree journey and there are many more varieties out there. Check them all out on our Cherry Tree Page!

Happy gardening!

Shop cherry trees
Previous Next

Frequently Asked Questions

Are cherries tart?

Cherry tartness depends entirely on the variety you grow. Sweet cherries like Bing and Lambert are mild and perfect for fresh eating, while sour cherries (Prunus cerasus varieties) deliver intense tartness that's ideal for pies, jams, and juice. Sour cherry varieties like Romeo Dwarf thrive in zones 4-7 and produce the most tart fruit. Choose sour cherry trees if you want that classic pucker-inducing tartness for baking and preserving.

Are tart cherries and sour cherries the same?

Yes, tart cherries and sour cherries are the same thing - both terms refer to Prunus cerasus varieties that are too acidic to eat fresh but perfect for baking and juice making. These cherries contrast with sweet cherries (Prunus avium) that you can enjoy straight from the tree. Sour cherry trees like Romeo Dwarf produce abundant fruit that's ideal for pies, jams, and tart cherry juice concentrate. Choose sour cherry varieties if you plan to bake or preserve your harvest rather than snacking fresh.

Which cherry tree is best for eating?

For fresh eating, choose sweet cherry varieties over sour cherries, which are too tart to enjoy straight from the tree. Sweet cherries thrive in USDA zones 5-9 and produce large, juicy fruit perfect for snacking during mid to late summer harvest. Popular eating varieties include Bing, Rainier, and Royal Ann, which develop their full sweetness when tree-ripened. Plant sweet cherry trees in full sun with well-draining soil for the best fruit quality and flavor.

What is the best cherry tree?

The best cherry tree depends on your intended use: sweet cherries like Bing or Rainier are perfect for fresh eating, while sour varieties like Montmorency or Romeo Dwarf excel for baking and juice-making. Sweet cherries typically require zones 5-9 and need cross-pollination, whereas sour cherries are more cold-hardy (zones 4-8) and self-fertile. Romeo Dwarf is particularly excellent for small spaces, staying under 8 feet tall while producing abundant tart fruit. Choose sweet varieties if you want to eat fresh fruit directly from the tree, or select sour cherries if you plan to make pies, jams, or tart cherry juice.

Are tart cherries different from regular cherries?

Yes, tart cherries (also called sour cherries) are distinctly different from sweet cherries. Tart cherries like Montmorency and Romeo Dwarf are extremely acidic when eaten fresh but develop exceptional flavor when cooked or processed into juice, making them ideal for pies, jams, and health beverages. Sweet cherries like Bing and Rainier are perfect for fresh eating right off the tree. Choose sour cherry varieties if you plan to bake or make juice, or sweet varieties if you want to snack directly from your harvest.

Are bing cherries sweet or tart?

Bing cherries are sweet cherries, not tart, making them perfect for fresh eating right off the tree. These large, dark red to nearly black cherries are among the most popular sweet varieties and thrive in USDA zones 5-9. Bing cherry trees typically ripen in mid to late summer and require cross-pollination with another sweet cherry variety like Stella or Black Tartarian. Plant your Bing cherry tree in full sun with well-draining soil for the best fruit production.

Are cherries sour?

Not all cherries are sour - it depends on the variety you choose. Sweet cherries like Bing and Lambert are perfect for fresh eating right off the tree, while sour cherries (also called tart or pie cherries) like Montmorency and Romeo Dwarf have a sharp, acidic flavor that's ideal for baking and juice-making. Sour cherry varieties actually provide more antioxidants and are easier to grow in zones 4-7 than their sweet counterparts. Choose sweet varieties if you want fresh snacking fruit, or plant sour cherries for cooking, baking, and preserving.

What USDA hardiness zones are best for sweet cherry trees versus tart cherry trees?

Sweet cherry trees thrive in USDA zones 5-9, requiring mild winters and warm, dry summers for optimal fruit production. Tart cherry trees are more cold-hardy and perform well in zones 4-7, tolerating colder temperatures and more variable spring weather than their sweet counterparts. Sweet cherries need consistent temperatures above 60°F during growing season, while tart cherries can handle cooler summers. Check your specific zone and local climate conditions before selecting your variety, as microclimates within zones can significantly impact tree success.

How far apart should I space pie cherry trees from sweet cherry trees for pollination?

Plant pie cherry trees within 50-100 feet of sweet cherry varieties to ensure adequate cross-pollination by bees and other pollinators. Most tart cherries like Montmorency are self-fertile and don't require a pollinator, but sweet cherries need cross-pollination from compatible varieties that bloom at the same time in your zone. Sweet cherries should be spaced 20-25 feet apart from each other, while tart cherries can be planted 15-20 feet apart. Check your specific varieties' bloom times and ensure at least two compatible trees are planted within pollinator flight distance for optimal fruit set.

When is the best time to plant sour cherry trees in my garden?

The best time to plant sour cherry trees is during the dormant season in late fall through early spring, typically November through March, depending on your hardiness zone. In zones 4-6 where most sour cherries thrive, plant 4-6 weeks before your last hard freeze in spring or after leaf drop in fall when soil is still workable. Avoid planting during summer heat stress or when soil is frozen solid. Choose a location with full sun and well-draining soil, spacing trees 15-20 feet apart for proper air circulation.

Find Your Garden's Growing Zone!

Your Current Growing Zone:

Zone

ZIP Code:

✓ Growing Zone Set Successfully!

Your zone has been saved and will be used throughout the site.

⚠ Unable to locate a growing zone for that ZIP code.

Please check your ZIP code and try again.

Looking up your growing zone...

When ordering a tree or plant, make sure to know your planting zone.

You can determine your garden's USDA hardiness zone by entering your Zip Code below.